Thursday, October 18, 2007

Bollocks from the FCO

Yesterday I highlighted an article on the EU Constitution or what is now disingenuously called a "Treaty".

During my search on the web I turned up the "Official" Supporters club for the Treaty at the Foreign and Commonwealth Office website, this was not difficult to find as it is currently an advertised (paid for by us) link on Google.

Now today we find out via the Coffee House blog in the Spectator that the Independent has peddled out some of the Labour spin on the site as original work. The article examines some supposed myths about the "Treaty". Unfortunately most of these myths have now been discovered to be truths.

This is not the worst of the FCO site taking the following on the front page.

Why is the Reform Treaty in the news now?

The mandate for the EU Reform Treaty was agreed by the prime ministers or presidents of all EU countries in the European Council in June.

The final text of the Treaty - which is currently being written - will have to be approved by all EU countries, following their own constitutional procedures, before it can come into effect.

In the UK, all Treaties, including EU Treaties, are submitted to Parliament, which has the right to examine and debate them in detail.

There is currently a lot of speculation in the media about what the Reform Treaty will mean for the UK. Some people believe that the UK should not agree to the Reform Treaty until it has been put to a public vote in this country (a referendum).

Many people who are opposed to the Reform Treaty are also opposed in principle to the UK's membership of the EU; others want a referendum because they believe that the Reform Treaty would transfer too much power from the UK to the EU.

These are serious issues that demand public attention. However, the fact is that many things that have been said and written about the Reform Treaty are simply not factually accurate.

It then links to the EU Treaty myths, the subject of the Independent Front page.

Lets look at the implications here

1) That it is only Eurosceptics who don't want the treaty, it lumps the many People who are opposed in the group of people who don't want Britain in the EU at all. This is simply incorrect. Whilst it will be true that virtually all people who oppose the EU will oppose the treaty, there are many more who support the EU but oppose the Treaty (myself included).

2) That some people believe that the UK should not agree to the Reform. No mention that only 29% would vote for the treaty against 47% who would vote against it.

3) That some people think there should be a referendum, no it's not "some" people it is 66% of people who want Labour to keep their promise of a referendum.

4) Of course it doesn't mention any of the major reasons that it might just be in the news, such as the frailty of the red lines, the manifesto promises that are being broken, the Parliamentary committee who reported that the Treaty was the constitution in all but name, etc, etc.

This is just one example of the crap that the FCO is trying to peddle to the country as the truth on this website. It is a disgrace to the Government and to this country.

EU Reform Treaty Foreign & Commonwealth Office

2 comments:

McNoddy said...

Reasons for not having a referendum...

1) Despite the semantics - there is no need as quite rightly espoused by Mr Broon in parliament at last PMQ. The govt has redlined those issues worth worrying about. Time to say well done where it's merited.

2) Only Eire must call a referendum - no-one else is.

3) Bloody expensive and the vast majority of UK citizens don't give a hoot, don't understnd and lastly would only use it to beat with a stick the PARTY line they disagree with and blow the actual consequences or relevance of the choice put to them.

4) Bound to be on my day off and yet another one cancelled as a result.

p.s.
Didn't the Tories vote in the HOC against a referendum last time round?

... and no I don't vote Labour.

Anonymous said...

Noddy, Labour, the Libdems and the Conservatives all promised a referendum in their last manifesto. At the moment the Tories are the only party who are keeping that promise, the other two will vote this through having broken their promise.
More interestingly the SNP have now decide that Holyrood should vote on the issue and they will be pressing for one.
Tories and Tarten Tories on the same side in Scotland, wonders will never cease.